Last updated:
Use this free rent vs buy calculator to see whether renting or buying leaves you with more money after the years you plan to stay. Enter the home price, mortgage details and your rent, then press Calculate. A mortgage builds equity and rent does not, but a renter keeps the cash a buyer ties up in a house, so the calculator puts both on the same footing and also shows the break-even year and break-even rent.
Buying
Renting
Assumptions you can change
Rent vs buy calculator examples
1. Buying comes out ahead. A $400,000 home with 20% down, a 6.5% 30-year mortgage, property tax of 1.1%, $1,800 a year in insurance, against rent of $2,300 a month plus $15 renter’s insurance, over 10 years with the default assumptions. At the end of year 10 the home is worth $537,566.55, selling costs are $32,253.99 and the mortgage balance is $271,283.60. Buying is $9,677.59 ahead: net worth of $234,028.95 against $224,351.36 for the renter. Buying stays ahead from year 9. If home prices grew 2% a year instead of 3%, buying would be $32,104 behind after 10 years.
2. Break-even rent. The same purchase with the rent left blank. Over 10 years, a starting rent of $2,247.30 a month makes renting and buying equal. Rent above that favors buying, and rent below it favors renting.
3. Renting comes out ahead. A $350,000 home with 5% down ($17,500), PMI at 0.8% a year, $1,600 a year in insurance, against rent of $2,100 a month, over 7 years. PMI alone costs $18,620.00 in that time. Renting is $24,484.14 ahead: $128,478.63 against $103,994.49. Buying stays ahead only from year 13, and the break-even rent is $2,317.67.
Estimates only, not a forecast, a recommendation or financial advice. The results depend heavily on the assumptions, which are round-number examples and not predictions. Taxes are off unless you enter a rate. Rates, costs and rules differ by place and lender.
Quick answer: Buying usually wins when you stay long enough, because the home grows in value and the loan balance shrinks. Renting usually wins on short stays, because buying and selling a home costs thousands in fees. For example, a $400,000 home with 20% down and a 6.5% 30-year mortgage, compared with $2,300 monthly rent, leaves the buyer $9,677.59 ahead after 10 years. At 2% yearly price growth instead of 3%, the buyer is $32,104 behind. The result depends heavily on your assumptions, so change them and see.
How to use the calculator
- Enter the home price, down payment, mortgage rate and loan term.
- Add yearly property tax and home insurance, plus HOA fees if you have them.
- Enter your monthly rent and renter’s insurance. You can leave rent blank to get only the break-even rent.
- Set how many years you plan to stay, from 1 to 30.
- Review the assumptions (price growth, rent increase, investment return and so on) and change any that do not fit your case.
- Press Calculate, or press Try example to load a worked case.
If your down payment is under 20%, enter a PMI rate. The calculator charges PMI until the loan falls to 80% of the purchase price.
How the two options are compared
The calculator runs month by month for up to 30 years.
The buyer pays: closing costs, mortgage payments, property tax, home insurance, HOA fees, maintenance, and selling costs at the end.
The renter pays: rent and renter’s insurance. Rent rises every year at the rate you set.
Many simple calculators skip the next part. The renter invests the down payment and closing costs on day one. Each month, whoever spends less invests the difference. Early on the buyer’s monthly cost is often higher, so the renter invests the gap. Later, rent may overtake the mortgage and the roles flip.
At the end:
- Buyer’s net worth = home value − selling costs − loan balance + any savings.
- Renter’s net worth = investments.
The larger number wins. The difference is the headline result.
Worked example
| Item | Buying | Renting |
|---|---|---|
| Home value after 10 years | $537,566.55 | n/a |
| Selling costs (6%) | −$32,253.99 | n/a |
| Mortgage balance | −$271,283.60 | n/a |
| Savings and investments | $0.00 | $224,351.36 |
| Net worth | $234,028.95 | $224,351.36 |
The home price grows 3% a year, rent starts at $2,300 and grows 3%, and investments earn 6%. Buying is ahead by $9,677.59. It has stayed ahead for good since year 9.
Over those 10 years, buying also costs $193,997.73 in mortgage interest, $50,441.07 in property tax and $45,855.52 in maintenance. Those costs exclude the loan principal you repay, which builds equity.
What moves the result most
| Assumption | Effect |
|---|---|
| Home price growth | The biggest swing. Higher growth favors buying strongly. |
| Years you stay | Longer stays spread out the fees and favor buying. |
| Mortgage rate | A higher rate raises interest cost and favors renting. |
| Investment return | A higher return makes the renter’s invested cash grow faster. |
| Rent increases | Faster rent growth favors buying. |
| Down payment | Under 20% adds PMI, which can tip a close case toward renting. |
The sensitivity table in the results shows the buyer’s advantage or deficit for different price growth rates and stay lengths, so you can see how fragile a result is.
Break-even year and break-even rent
Break-even year is the first year after which buying stays ahead through the end of your timeline. If buying only pulls ahead after year 13 and you plan to stay 7 years, renting is the better fit. The example $350,000 home with 5% down and PMI works this way: renting comes out $24,484.14 ahead over 7 years, and buying only catches up in year 13.
Break-even rent is the starting monthly rent that makes both options equal after your chosen stay. In the first example it is $2,247.30 a month. If your actual rent is higher, buying looks better. If it is lower, renting does. Because the calculator also raises that rent by your yearly increase, the comparison stays fair over time.
What the calculator does not include
- Taxes. Mortgage interest and property tax deductions, and tax on investment gains, are off by default. You can enter rates in the assumptions.
- Non-financial factors. Stability, flexibility, the freedom to renovate, and the stress of repairs matter, but they have no price tag here.
- Market swings. It uses steady yearly rates, and real markets rise and fall.
Treat the result as a simplified estimate, not a forecast.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to rent or buy a house?
It depends on how long you stay, how fast home prices rise in your area, your mortgage rate, and what return your savings could earn. Buying often wins over 8 to 10 years or more. For shorter stays, renting often does. Run your own numbers to see.
How long do you have to stay for buying to pay off?
That is the break-even year in the results. In the main example it is year 9. With a smaller down payment and PMI, it was year 13. There is no single answer.
Why does the calculator assume the renter invests money?
Cash that a buyer puts into a down payment cannot also earn a return. Counting that lost return is called opportunity cost, and leaving it out makes buying look better than it is. You can lower the investment return in the assumptions if you prefer.
What is a fair rent compared with buying?
Use the break-even rent. If comparable rentals in your area cost less than that figure, renting is financially stronger for the stay you entered. If they cost more, buying is stronger.
This calculator gives estimates for information only. It is not a forecast, a recommendation or financial advice. Rates, costs and rules differ by place and lender, so check them before you decide.
